Good for Nothing (2 of 3): The Right University, and Then?

This is the second of a three-part series based on my keynote, A Wider Answer, to the Bangkok CIS-EARCOS Institute on International Admission & Guidance in September 2026.

In part one, I argued that we judge education almost entirely by what it leads to, and that the pressure to do so has moved inside us. 

While that worries me, I am not saying we should stop caring about excellence, or stop encouraging young people to develop. I’m pointing to our biggest assumption: that the purpose of education is to produce something in the future, not the present. A qualification, a College place, a career. Work hard, and doors will open. From my story in part 1, practise the piano for the future I’ve chosen for you. Or from the Iroquois story, learn to take a deer so you can be a good hunter. 

This instrumental deal has shaped education for a few hundred years, and for many millions of people it has been a lifeline – the route out of poverty, to lives better than their parents had. The argument may be different for those for whom education was the only way up, so I don’t entirely dismiss that deal. It has worked, and it continues to work for many. But there are two sides to every deal and we should keep track of – or at least name and think about – both sides of the ledger.

I believe there is something else other than the instrumental deal – something real that you can see on any nursery floor, where a three-year-old building a tower of blocks is not reading market signals for employability; something in her drives her to build. Or you can see it among the Theory of Knowledge students who are not chasing the credential but grappling with the complexity of their paradigms, and realising there are other options. They are also driven to do it because something in them needs to, when presented with compelling ideas. There is, in other words, more than just the product. 

I fear we have looked at what the drive produces – civilisation, technology, material progress – and somewhere along the way, forgotten that there is any difference between the product and the purpose. Or indeed, that there is any purpose beyond a distant future at all.

Some years ago, a father came to see me about his daughter. She was bright and capable, and I taught her Theory of Knowledge – and although it is actually an eminently practical subject, I accept that the practicality is not entirely obvious; so his question was entirely reasonable: what will she do with this? I gave him the standard answer. Transferable skills, critical thinking, creativity – the skills that employers value. He was polite but unconvinced, and honestly, perhaps I am beginning to be too.

What I should have said was that the question assumed that if the study didn’t lead anywhere, it was wasted. But some things don’t lead anywhere because they aren’t on the way to anywhere – they’re where you arrive. His daughter wasn’t only studying for what it might lead to. She was being changed by the ideas in the lessons themselves: becoming a different person from the one she’d have become had she not studied them. I didn’t have the language to say that, so I conceded his whole premise. I answered the instrumental question instead of opening a conversation about it.

“What will she do with this?” asks about the product.

“Who will she become by doing this?” asks about the person. 

The systems we run are largely organised around the first – university rankings, graduate employment statistics, earning premiums by degree subject, all of them answering the product question. The second is harder to measure, so it gets pushed to the margins as a nice-to-have.

That includes most schools – certainly the one I lead. Every year we publish our IB results and our university destinations. They are important and I’m not embarrassed by that – in fact I’m proud of the results; they represent years of work. But they address only the first question. So when I talk about the instrumental system, I’m inside the tent.

One place where the instrumental logic shows up clearly is in the move toward early specialisation. The pressure to build a profile, develop a USP, curate a CV. For many this is not just a preference but a whole strategy, planned years in advance. It comes from so many places – from rankings, from our schools, communities and from the achievement culture I have been describing. It feels rational; if the world is competitive, get ahead early. Find your thing and double down on it.

David Epstein, in his book Range, makes a compelling case that there’s more to it than this. He starts with Tiger Woods. Everything in the Tiger Woods story supports the idea that early, narrow focus is the route to greatness. You may be familiar with Amy Chua’s Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother which promotes the same logic from the parenting side: relentless, aggressive, narrowly focused.

But Epstein argues that this path works only in what he calls “kind” environments – constrained, predictable, repeatable domains where the rules are clear and fixed, and feedback is immediate. Golf is one such environment. But most of life is not like that. Life is what Hogarth calls “wicked” – the rules are unclear, the goal (if there is one) is unclear, and feedback comes in years, not seconds. In those environments, and this is most of what our students will face, it is the generalists who tend to thrive. 

David Epstein also notes that in a study of 1,200 young musicians, there was a strong link between a child not choosing their instrument and quitting. The most successful musicians only started practising more when they identified the instrument they themselves wanted to focus on. Even Amy Chua’s daughter Lulu, raised under the Tiger Mother regime, quit violin at thirteen despite extraordinary potential. As Lulu herself put it: she did not choose the violin. We could say that Lulu failed, but we might also wonder if Lulu actually understood the problem very well – takign into account what it felt like from the inside; like the boy and the piano, perhaps. That the boy was utterly ungifted and rather reluctant is beside the point.

Thia tension is familiar. We all know the student with the curated profile, the strategic extracurriculars, the brand management of the personal statement. And we know the student who has tried many things, changed direction, followed interests that don’t add up to a neat narrative. Our systems tend to reward the first student, but Epstein’s evidence suggests the second may be better prepared for what comes next. That should trouble us

You will have spotted what I did there, by the way – what was smuggled into my argument. I argued that breadth produces better outcomes in unpredictable environments, so let’s go for that. I said “better prepared for what comes next”. In other words I was justifying breadth in terms of what it led to, not as valuable in itself. I was critiquing instrumentalism, but I’ve just replaced one instrumental argument with another. That’s how ingrained the instrumental reflex is – almost inescapable.

That reflex is at the core of my argument. The point is that if something is always in service of something else, then when you finally get to that next thing, that’s also in service of something else. And we’ve seen that by the student who thinks that getting the 45 points on the IB will be great, and then it’s getting into the right University, and then it’s being the valedictorian, and then it’s getting the job, and then it’s becoming a partner, and so on. If everything is in service of something else, then where does it end? What’s the ground we can stop at? The spiral has to stop somewhere, unless, as the old story has, it’s ‘turtles all the way down’. There has to be something.

I want to suggest that the spiral can stop at the point where something is valuable not for what it leads to, but for what it does to you. Where it changes you. That ground is the thing that is not in service of anything else, because being changed is not a step on the way to somewhere; it is the somewhere. In the language of this series, it is good for nothing.

Now you might ask “what change is the valuable one that grounds everything?” but I am not going to specify what anyone should change into because the moment I do – the moment I name the better things we should be looking for – we will have defined more targets, more gaps to close. Instrumentalism will force its way in again, just as it did for the Range example, because that’s how our systems work and suddenly it’ll be a metric on the way to success and we’re back in the instrumental spiral.

(That, by the way, is a difficulty with moves to drop exam grades on transcripts and instead report on qualities like critical thinking, creativity and communication and so on, because the instrumental approach will simply move the game to those very qualities. The danger is that we simply play the same game with different pieces, thinking it’s a real change).

Instrumentalism is the universal acid here. It can dissolve anything – turn ineffable qualities into metrics, reduce richness to a strategy. So I will point to the general direction – the openness to be changed by what you meet. That is a ground we can stop at. To say more, to name a quality, build a rubric for it, would be to hand the achievement society its next target.

Next: what a good life might look like, and what it means for schools and families.

References

  • Graphics by Gemini, prompt by Claude
  • Chua, A. (2011). Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother. Penguin.
  • Epstein, D. (2019). Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World. Riverhead.
  • Hogarth, R. M. (2001). Educating Intuition. University of Chicago Press.

Share this article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

NEW BOOK · MARCH 2027

Connection

A Year of Great Conversations with Your Teen

By Nicholas Alchin

A practical guide to helping parents build meaningful conversations and stronger connections with their pre-teens and teenagers.

Pre-order your copy →