Innovation in Schools: 50 years in… what’s next?

That’s a specific issue of what we find we are increasingly facing – the need to resist simple answers to binary questions – do we want X or Y? (when X and Y are both good but may appear opposed) and instead to seek ways to manage to have both X and Y as far as we can. We refer to many of these apparently irreconcilable tensions as polarities; where we need both dimensions of a continuum.

This is hardly a new idea – as parents we need provide both unconditional love and firm discipline. Neither alone is sufficient, and our focus has to move from one to other as necessary – it’s hard to be too precise about that; the best we can do is to be aware of the need for both – and the dangers if we stick with only one for too long.

Once named like this – polarities are situations to manage, not problems to solve, we can start to see they arise very frequently indeed, in personal and professional situations.

In each of these cases, it’s easy to see that while we might have to focus on one aspect of each pair at any given time it would be foolish to forget about the other element. As far as innovation goes it seems to me that we’ve often identified the incorrect pair; we tend to think of innovation as paired with stasis or stagnation – but as I said I don’t think innovation is really an option these days; the only question is the pace and extent of the innovation. The real focus should be between disruptive innovation and incremental innovation, to put it in current business parlance. We need both; and we need to be deliberate about how we approach this as we head into our second half century.

As we think about this polarity we need to look at the benefits of each side but also not be blind to the downsides of an exclusive focus on any one side. Framing the situation like this is a good step in the first direction.

What’s likely to come out of this thinking? Well, this isn’t the place for any announcement, but one thing we can say is that we should here be only talking about means and not ends. Our UWCSEA Mission to make education a force for a peaceful and sustainable future remains unchanged; the question is how to deliver that Mission with greater power. So there is a fixed point, an agreed destination; and the challenges and opportunities are more to do with the VUCA world we live in. What we are finding is that there are no simple paths from A and B; things look more like the topographical map below, where the black line is naive, and with the added caveat that the mountains are being eroded and uplifted as we speak, uplifted here, with the rivers flooding and even the occasional covid volcano going off (we have not yet been hit by an asteroid). Under such a topography, there is a real question over the validity of long-term fixed plans. What we have to know is that we need to head in particular direction, and that it won’t be a straight line.